Tall wood buildings, often referred to as "mass timber" or "cross-laminated timber (CLT)" structures, present several unique acoustic challenges.
More...
These challenges arise from the differences in sound insulation, vibration transmission, and damping properties compared to traditional steel or concrete structures.
A 14-story experimental wood building is under construction at the University of Toronto campus. More information is in the Toronto Star article. Even taller buildings were recently built in British Columbia
Acoustic challenges of tall buildings construction
Here are some critical acoustic challenges associated with tall wood buildings:
1. Airborne Sound Insulation
Problem: Wood is less dense than concrete or steel, reducing mass and, consequently, performing poorly in blocking airborne sound. This means that sounds from adjacent spaces, such as voices or music, are more easily heard through walls and floors.
Solution: Increasing the mass of wood assemblies by adding layers of gypsum board, using resilient channels, or incorporating additional sound-absorbing materials can improve airborne sound insulation. The architect must incorporate this solution.
2. Impact Noise Transmission
Problem: Impact sounds, like footsteps or moving furniture, are more easily transmitted in wood structures due to the material’s lower damping capacity and higher flexibility than concrete.
Solution: Use floating floors, underlayment with high impact insulation ratings, and resilient mounts to decouple the floor from the structure, reducing the transmission of impact noise. The ceiling drywall must be resiliently attached to the underside of the structural elements,
3. Structure-Borne Noise
Problem: Vibrations caused by mechanical systems, elevators, or even external sources like wind can be more pronounced in wood structures. Wood's lightweight and flexible nature can amplify these vibrations, leading to noise issues.
Solution: Mitigating these issues requires decoupling mechanical systems from the building structure, using vibration isolation mounts, and carefully designing the building’s structural components. This is much more involved in wood buildings than in concrete buildings, requiring the involvement of an acoustical consultant.
4. Flanking Sound Transmission
Problem: Sound can bypass barriers by travelling along building elements such as walls, floors, and ceilings. This flanking transmission can be more prominent in wood buildings due to the interconnected nature of wooden components.
Solution: Detailed attention to construction joints, sealing gaps, and using acoustic breaks between connected elements can reduce flanking transmission. The architect needs to consult the National Research Council database of mass timber assemblies and apply this information in the design.
5. Low-frequency noise
Problem: Due to the material's natural resonance characteristics, low-frequency sounds, such as bass notes from music or heavy machinery, can be more challenging to control in wood buildings.
Solution: Designing wall and floor assemblies to target specific low-frequency ranges, using damping materials, and incorporating mass-loaded barriers can help address low-frequency noise issues. However, in most cases, the acoustic performance of heavy concrete structures cannot be matched.
6. Building Code Acoustic Requirements
Problem: Meeting building code requirements for sound insulation and noise control can be more challenging with wood structures, particularly as codes evolve to address the growing popularity of mass timber buildings.
Solution: Collaboration with acoustic engineers and consultants early in the design process is essential to meet all acoustic performance criteria.
7. Fire protection
Problem: Besides acoustical challenges, fire protection creates new issues in tall wood buildings.
Solution: The architect must carefully design the fire protection details in the building. However, the fire protection works in a completed building. Buildings under construction, with incomplete fire protection measures, cause new challenges. Here is an example of a fire in a building under construction:
Conclusion - acoustic challenges
Addressing these acoustic challenges and fire protection in tall wood buildings requires innovative design, material selection, and construction techniques. With proper attention to detail, mass timber buildings can be created that not only meet but exceed modern acoustic performance standards.
If you would like a quote from the author of this article and an acoustical consultant, please use the buttons below.
We appreciate your feedback. Please send us a message:
